Ten weeks ago I posted my list of what I intended to buy from the DC Comics New 52. To recap, they were:
Then through browsing the racks at the store, I added the following, based on something I saw in the title or a page-turn, or in the case of Animal Man, a good review:
Based solely on what I read in Issue #1 of each, I decided to not go forward with the following titles:
I reviewed Action Comics #1 here. Just not the Superman I was interested in reading about, I guess. (All other DC Comics titles I have reviewed here include links in comic title names in this article).
Green Lantern #1 was spent exclusively on Sinestro, not Hal Jordan, and because I wasn’t interested in an ongoing Sinestro book, I gave up on buying Issue #2, which he also appears to be featured in.
Voodoo #1 was so thin in plot and long on shock factor that it made the bottom of the list of all that I read over the past three months. Not my cup of tea.
Supergirl #1 wasn’t bad. But I couldn’t help comparing it to Michael Turner’s and Jeph Loeb’s Supergirl from the Superman/Batman series and this just didn’t compare.
Birds of Prey was a series I read in about 5-10 issue arcs over several years. This isn’t the same team, and it’s not worse because there is no Oracle, it is just not the same sensibility. I prefer the more mature, aka women heroine vs. girl heroine Birds of Prey group of the past, and I don’t like at all where the current Black Canary is, they should get her back in the Green Arrow title. I think the characters are drawn almost like teenagers, as if this should be a companion to the Teen Titans. That would make more sense. So I left this title behind after Issue #1, too.
I decided to go forward and read Issue #2 of the following titles, however, just to give them another shot (I plan to review each Issue #2 at a later date):
So this is how five titles were cut from my pull-list. The big winners? I have eight titles I hope to be reading for a long time:
I will also keep buying Green Arrow in hopes that it will improve, and Jim Lee’s Justice League since it seems to glue a lot of the other stories together.
Frankly, eight is about the right number I wanted to end up with, especially at current comic book prices. I also will keep reading til the end of the short series, Huntress. And as I get into more Marvel Comics I will be adding at least one book from that publisher to the ongoing read pile, in addition to independent publisher books Bionic Man and Rachel Rising.
So was the first round of the New 52 successful? Ultimately most of what I read was worth reading, so I’d answer a definite “yes“. I read 21 of the 52 titles, more than I planned to read. The biggest surprise? How much I liked All-Star Western #1 and its mix of old Gotham City and Jonah Hex. Captain Atom and Justice League Dark were the two books I was most curious about, and they both delivered in a big way stellar stories and art about more minor DC Comics characters that I now can’t wait to read more about.
C.J. Bunce
Editor
borg.com
