Now streaming — The End of Oak Street comes to HBO Max

Review by C.J. Bunce

All of the ideas mashed together to become the latest Anne Hathaway movie probably made more sense on paper.  The End of Oak Street was made by J.J. Abrams’ Bad Robot studio and even looks like a follow-up to Abrams’ 2011 coming-of-age sci-fi movie Super 8.  The movie is set in 1982, which reels in the nostalgia for the 1980s revived by Stranger Things.  And it’s an attempt to capture audiences’ love for Michael Crichton and Steven Spielberg’s Jurassic Park.  Add to it co-star Ewan McGregor.  Ripples in space form a wormhole that blips a neighborhood back 60 million years.  Dinosaurs wander into a 1980s Atlanta suburb standing in for small town Michigan.  Bodies are chomped.  At the center of the story is a couple heading for divorce, just the kind of centerpiece for a Steven Spielberg-style family movie, like E.T. or Close Encounters.  It even has Abrams’ go-to composer, Michael Giacchino, along for the music.

So why doesn’t The End of Oak Street work?

Too much of the family drama?  Is it a feeling of uneasiness for the viewer that never goes away?  Is it because of its lack of heart and hope?  McGregor’s attempt at an American Midwest accent?  The script settles in on its depressing family elements and barely scrabbles its way out in the last minutes.  Is the problem its uneven tone?  Is it because there’s no explanation for a neighborhood of families not shouting at each other to try to figure out what is happening?  Is it because monsters are everywhere and the family chooses to discuss their personal problems out in the wide open, middle of the street at the worst possible times, over and over?  Is it because Hathaway and McGregor’s flat characters have no chemistry?  Is it because the solution at the end is too convenient?

Nothing is better than a great mash-up, but the best mash-ups know what they are.  M. Night Shyamalan’s supernatural movies tend toward a building, menacing sense of dread that leads to some goal requiring heroic action by the finale.  Jurassic Park, the movie, was carefully built upon a well-thought out, layered novel at least derived from many cutting-edge, scientific principles.  With The End of Oak Street, the audience can’t quite be sure this couple should be together at the end of the movie.  Denise, played by Hathaway, has an easy out at the end of the movie that would give her character some growth.  She chooses her husband Greg, played by Ewan McGregor, and her kids instead, sort of, and is rewarded with the secret desires she was hiding away–to write a book.  And that’s a nice thing for her, and her family survives.  That should feel like a win all around, right?

The End of Oak Street is closest in tonality to the Godzilla movies.  Kaiju devastate a town and leave destruction in their wake.  End of story.  But this happily ever after ending spoils that, and creates its own problems for the characters that aren’t even addressed–at least if typical sci-fi time travel rules apply.  Like the fact that a mom and her two kids are left to fend for themselves without their father/husband in some Jurassic past.  Why don’t Denise and the kids vanish as soon as mom makes several quick telephone calls at a phone booth?  Poof.  After all, a la The Sound of Thunder, she has changed the past by removing a player that aided her very survival.  To get to that spot.  To be able to make those phone calls.

Yes, it’s a survival movie.  Like the Jumanji movies.  Only not.  Those movies are comedies, so they are fun by their nature.  So this must be a survival-horror movie, like Abrams’ 10 Cloverfield Lane.  Those movies never try for happy endings.  Was writer director David Robert Mitchell aiming for A Quiet Place?  The family members all survive in Spielberg’s War of the Worlds.  Maybe that’s what this is?

Do we even need to address the special effects?  Audiences are so accustomed to the very real creatures from movies and shows like The Mandalorian, so that if your creatures aren’t believable, you’re going to lose viewers fast.  So many scenes are shot where the camera veers off screen before we see the visual element–Shyamalan has perfected that approach.  Mitchell hasn’t mastered that yet.  Check out Shyamalan’s Signs, another story of trapped people in a neighborhood, so see it done better.  Or this past year’s sci-fi spectacle Predator: Badlands.  Just one image of one dinosaur-like beast there runs circles around all the dino-footage in The End of Oak Street.

Sci-fi fans have seen the bones of this story before.  It’s The Twilight Zone episode “Stopover in a Quiet Town,” where a family like Denise’s find themselves also stuck in a town.  In that case a giant alien has them trapped in a kind of train set, but the angst and story all work in part because it’s horror, and the family doesn’t get out at the end.  With The End of Oak Street we have an impossible scenario that only the precocious teen daughter, played by Maisy Stella, can figure out.  In a scene that looks straight out of Honey, I Shrunk the Kids, Denise and the kids (and somehow the family pooch) get snapped back to reality.  Denise suddenly becomes clever at the end, doing things the audience had no idea she was capable of, only because Mitchell didn’t lay the groundwork for it.

Giacchino’s score has the frenetic angsty moments, but is missing the hope, triumph, and awe, like in Jurassic Park when John Williams showed us how to feel when we saw our first real Brontosaurus, or marveled at our first triceratops, or finally escaped at the end.  A scene is there–when Denise and Greg drive up to the stegosaurus pack, but their movements don’t look lifelike and it jars you out of the moment.  Two dinosaurs having sex isn’t really funny.  The timing is bad.  Maybe the movie just suffers from bad editing choices in post-production?

None of this would matter if the journey was consistent, if the movie was a fun ride.  If it was simply fun to watch.  And it may just work depending on your mood.  Or your patience in sitting through the family drama.  Some of the nostalgia choices are interesting, like picking a 1973 Dodge Coronet for the family car instead of Hollywood’s more typical selection of a 1970s Chevy.  McGregor’s shirts are perfect for the early 1980s.

At least the title is clever.  This is an unusual sci-fi movie that just doesn’t live up to its promise and had far greater potential.  Hathaway need not worry–she has four other movies in theaters this year: The Odyssey, Verity, Mother Mary, and The Devil Wears Prada 2.  The End of Oak Street is now streaming on HBO Max.

Leave a Reply